Judges get Copilot, defendants write appeals with AI: how AI entered Taiwan’s courts through two doors
In 2023 the Judicial Yuan wanted AI to write draft judgments in drink-driving and mule-account cases; after objections the plan was put on hold, and it has never gone live. But in August this year the Judicial Yuan gave every judge in Taiwan Microsoft 365 Copilot, and on 18 September it sent a letter warning judges not to use AI to generate judgments. On the other side of the courtroom, the Supreme Court dismissed a cash courier’s appeal that appeared to have been written by AI, and the Taipei District Court for the first time fined a litigant for abusive AI filings, imposing a penalty of NT$30,000. A new experiment shows that professionals went along with the AI’s leaning 86% of the time: “human review” is not necessarily an independent check.




